One year ago to the day, my first novel hit the shelves. It was called Shibboleth, sold for £14.99 from all the major bookselling chains, and made me feel, for two or three weeks following its publication, like the coolest person in the world. The reviews were by and large excellent; all the attractive, well-dressed people on the London literary circuit endlessly told me how funny it was; and in the first two weeks, it massively outsold the publishers’ expectations – despite the fact that I was only twenty-seven years old, had no social media presence to speak of, and didn’t know any novelists myself. I was even featured in a number of flattering magazine profiles, all of which made noisy reference to my youth and precocity – which at least made a nice change from concerned older family members anxiously inquiring as to why I didn’t have a job.
Of course, the slop-swilling masses were always going to get their snouts into my novel eventually. I was prepared for this, or so I thought: after all, not everyone on the planet can be a glamorous sort-of-friend on the London or New York literary circuit; it is the lot of some people to work in London graduate schemes, watch Traitors on television, compete at a semi-professional level in various Park Runs, and – however much I would like this not to be the case – these people are allowed to buy books, too.
Still, I wasn’t quite prepared for the absolute orgy of incomprehension that the next year or so would loose on my novel. In one sense, I hadn’t exactly helped myself. I had chosen to write about the culture war and campus politics. This was deliberate: I had believed that the novel, with its delicate dance of mutually ironising perspectives, would be the perfect vehicle to rise above the irritating tendencies in the discourse of the day – tendencies which I took to be the product of various kinds of systematic misunderstanding about the function of language which the novel, as a form, might help remedy. But in the end, it turns out, the logic of the culture war was far more powerful than I thought. Soon, retired army colonels were writing me error-riddled letters congratulating me on having the courage to ‘reckon with the Muslims’. Kindly-looking middle-aged women were taking me aside at literary events and asking me, in a conspiratorial whisper, what I thought of ‘all this trans nonsense’. On the other side of the aisle, things were even worse. To quote some of the lovely things posted on the Oxford University Subreddit, I was ‘embarrassing’, ‘the kind of guy who votes Reform’, and made one of the commenters ‘wanna shoot myself’. My novel itself was sneered at from every possible angle: ‘The premise sounds tedious. The plot sounds tedious. The person who has written it sounds extremely tedious.’ Not that they had read it of course. Reading a novel before passing judgement on it was considered very dangerous indeed.
When I have put this grievance to my friends, they have tended to suggest that I write a sort of explanatory addendum. Like Eliot’s notes to ‘The Waste Land’, except more whinily political: I’m not what you think I am; I’m one of the good guys; I am, in fact, so left wing, and so maniacally committed to various social justice-type causes, that it tends to ruin quite a lot of family events. Upon hearing that the big anniversary was approaching, one friend suggested that I use it as as occasion to write just such a document, perhaps publishing it on my massively neglected Substack with a title like ‘How to Approach My Novel.’ Reader, I tried. But whenever I start typing out the apologia, I stop. My palms begin to sweat: the whole exercise just seems so stupid and literal; another pointless ‘This is what I believe’ screed added to the bonfire.
I think, however, that I just might have found a solution. I can see it now, undulating into view in front of me, like a mirage in the desert. It is, admittedly a solution that is seriously frowned upon among professional writers. It is only really thinkable, in fact, if you are Luigi Pirandello, or some hideous fanfic creature from the abysses of Wattpad, or an actually diagnosed schizophrenic. But I’m going to try it anyway. It goes like this: the actual people of the actual world have failed you, so why not ask the characters of the novel what they think? Maybe they can give a better account of your novel than you can. In reality, it’s true you are a failure. But what are you to the voices gibbering on inside your head?
Youssef is the son of a wealthy Egyptian businessman, and, after a difficult adolescence at a British boarding school, spent most of his time at Oxford being so flamboyantly louche that nobody could make fun of him. He was the soul of my novel – a kind of spiritual guide to the main character, Edward, welcoming him and rebuking him in equal measure, instructing him in the ways of Islam whether he liked it or not. Now, Youssef has graduated; he has settled in a flat in Pimlico, and, having failed to find work in a bank on account of its third-class degree, has happily taken a job at his father’s shipping firm. I meet him at the London office, which is vast, and overlooks the river; he springs up from his office chair the moment he sees me at the door, makes a brief, unrepeatable comment about my appearance, and says:
‘So you want to know whether you are a success, I take it? Come, sit. I shall tell you. Youssef Chamakh is an excellent judge of his fellow man.’
‘Thank you. Yes, you’re right. So basically what I wanted…’
‘Now, first we must talk money. You sold copies, I take it?’
‘I mean, yes.’
‘But not enough to clothe yourself normally, it seems.’
‘What? What’s wrong with what I’m wearing? Wearing tweed when it’s twenty-eight degrees isn’t “normal”, Youssef. It’s deranged.’
‘Now, tell me. Are we talking more than, or less than, one million pounds sterling?’
‘What? I mean, obviously less.’
‘I see. So not that many copies, then.’
‘Youssef, no debut writer makes a million pounds sterling. The average UK advance for literary fiction is about five thousand pounds.’
‘Per what?’
‘What?’
‘Five thousand pounds per what?’
‘No, it’s not… Forget it. Why are you so obsessed with money, anyway?’
‘Because, Thomas, I take an interest in your continued existence – as you may have noticed, my continued existence is rather intimately bound up with such matters. And I am afraid that five thousand pounds a month is not enough for a human being to live on, even a particularly withered and degraded example of one such as yourself.’
‘Right. Thanks for that.’
‘Not in London, at any rate. You’ll starve. You will have to live in some kind of underpass. You will start to eat out of bins. You will start to masturbate at tourists. Goodness, look at you, you’ve probably started already…’
‘My publisher says I might get some royalties soon.’
‘The Shi’ites say the Mahdi will return from his occultation soon, but that is pretty obviously not going to happen. Now listen, do you want a job or not? This is why you came here, I presume?’
‘What? No, that’s not why I…’
‘I mean we can’t give you to clients – look at you. You could be a secretary, maybe. You’ll have to wear a low-cut top. Will this be an issue?’
‘I wanted to try and work out whether I’ve been a success, Youssef.’
‘Well it’s pretty obvious whether a writer is a success or not, isn’t it?’
‘Is it?’
‘I mean presumably the success of a writer is a matter of having produced good writing. Have you produced good writing?’
‘Erm, I think so.’
‘Thomas. Look at me. What would have happened if the Prophet had said, when approached by the rabbi Abdullah ibn Salam and asked whether he Allah had disclosed to him the first sign of the hour and the first food of Paradise, something like “Erm, I think so”? We would all be Jews. A hideous prospect.’
‘I think we’re getting off topic.’
‘Listen, you seem to have chosen an artistic pursuit – and I use that term extremely advisedly – to produce something that you think of value outside the various mechanisms for apportioning value. Which is fine. Lots and lots of lovely words – just what the world needs. Who could object? But then you seem to want your work to be so good that it then brings the values of the whole world into line with yours, and you are duly showered with cash. And this, I am afraid, seems to be asking rather a lot.’
‘I just want to be able to make rent.’
‘And do you?’
‘Yes, but…’
‘Then what are you worrying about, my happy little serf?’
‘My friends have started buying houses. They work in literally the most pointless things ever in human history – corporate law, finance, insurance, “fintech”, whatever that means – and the world has given them houses. Where they can live!’
‘Some people, Thomas, might call literature pointless.’
‘That’s ridiculous. Literature matters, Youssef.’
‘So you say.’
‘It matters.’
‘I’m not arguing with you.’
‘Yes you are. I can hear it in your voice.’
‘I don’t have a voice. If you hear it in my voice it’s because you can hear it in your own head.’
‘Shut up!’
‘I will as soon as you actually want me to.’
‘I said shut up!’
Conrad is the only character in the novel even more debauched than Youssef. The two attended the same public school, but whereas Youssef was something of an up-and-comer, Conrad is a genuine aristocrat. He was always cuttingly amoral, but now, as an adult, he seems to have become genuinely malignant. Though he basically thinks the concept of work to be beneath him – a point of view with which I admittedly have some sympathy – he keeps the wheels turning by working at ‘politically unaffiliated’ think tank based on Tufton Street. I meet him at the East India Club, and he waves me over, briefly inquires whether we might have met each other at the Unherd Christmas Party, and says:
‘Now listen, I haven’t read your book yet, but I’m a fan. Big fan. Sit down by the way. You can have the chair under Disraeli portrait.’
‘Right. Sorry, how can you be a big fan without having read me?’
‘You were in every newspaper, Thomas. Gushing encomia in the Times. Fountains of praise in The Telegraph. Panegyrics worthy of Gorgias himself in The Daily Mail.’
‘Ah yes, “every newspaper”.’
‘And I know the central thesis of the novel, anyway. I’ve had it summarised by one of my smooth-cheeked interns.’
‘I mean, I don’t really think of it as having a central thesis. I don’t really think novels have a central thesis.’
‘Come, Thomas. I know what you’re up to. Sticking it to this woke nonsense. It’s admirable.’
‘The word “woke” doesn’t appear in the novel once.’
‘The words “gay pornography of dubious legality” don’t appear in the video I was watching before you came in, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t a pretty good description of what it was.’
‘But even the term “anti-woke” is question-begging, isn’t it? For instance: to some people ‘woke’ means a certain, exclusionary bourgeois etiquette. I’m definitely against that. But for some people it means a kind of common-sense egalitarianism. Women should be equal, ethnic minorities shouldn’t be shouted at in the street. Things like that. And I’m definitely not trying to criticise those things. In fact what I’m really trying to do is cleave apart these two conceptions.’
‘Goodness, listen to yourself. Have some courage, man! Say what you mean, for once. You’re fed up with all these black women writing fifty thousand words about their hair and instantly getting six figure book deals. You’re fed up with exciting new non-binary voices being shortlisted for prizes. You’re seething with ressentiment. Didn’t you get passed up for a prize the other day?’
‘You’re talking like every novel that’s ever been published is a spontaneous emanation from the worst atavisms in the novelist’s psyche.’
‘Isn’t it?’
‘No. Not at all. In fact, I spend half of my time editing trying to expunge my own opinions in the novel, so that the characters can speak.’
‘Oh god, I hate it when novelists talk like this. We are not real, you know.’
‘You are. I make you real. Just because something has been created it doesn’t mean they’re not real. And as a result, it’s pretty galling that when, say, one of the worst characters in the novel – someone like you, for instance, no offence…’
‘None taken.’
‘When someone like you says something heinous, I’m immediately assumed to be endorsing everything that character says.’
‘Don’t you think that just happens because you give me all the funniest lines?’
‘Well, maybe. But the point of the humour is to show that there is a kind of systematic repression at play that characterises all bureaucratic attempts to encode or stipulate formal equality, and that requires an undercurrent of perversity to sustain it. And the fact that horrible things are often the funniest, and the horrible characters are often the funniest – again, I’m sorry, I really don’t want to offend…’
‘Thomas, of all the highly unbelievable things you’ve ever said I think “I don’t want to offend” is the hardest to believe of all.’
‘The fact that they’re the funniest is a kind of challenge to the reader, to prompt them to re-examine the relationship between formal, stated commitments and their own beliefs.’
‘This, I’m afraid, is pure, unbridled, humanities drivel. You used to be so refreshingly allergic to all that. Remember “Seas incarnadine: Shakespeare, Macbeth and the menstruating body”? That made me laugh.’
‘But the joke there is that it’s actually a completely legitimate avenue for enquiry. I mean, have you read Macbeth? It’s full of interacting images of blood and womanhood. Honestly, you’re as bad as the Reddit people, Conrad. The whole point is that the book is written in this third person discourse that masquerades as neutral, denotative, but whose neutrality is slowly questioned by the characters in the novel.’
‘Right. Well, I’m afraid this seems like something you’ve made up literally on the spot.’
‘The whole book is called Shibboleth! Its whole name is an anticipation of precisely this dynamic!’
‘Well, I didn’t pick that up I’m afraid. And nor did any of my colleagues. Did you meet Jacob, by the way?’
‘No-one got it!’
‘So let me get this straight. Absolutely no-one on the planet got what you were trying to say in your little novel. But it’s not your fault?’
Liberty is twenty-four years old, African American, and while she was studying in Oxford she was pretty much the student body’s queen bee. Most of my fans in the lunatic fringes Tory party seem to think her-pre-eminence was a direct result of the fact that she was black; I, however, have always suspected it had far more to do with the fact that she is American – and was therefore more familiar with the weird institutional dynamics that have come to characterise the contemporary university, and which British people still find scary and alien. Interestingly, unlike a lot of her contemporaries, Liberty did not simply sell out after graduating. After a few months’ professional activism, she gained a scholarship to study critical theory at a prestigious American graduate school – certainly not Oxford, though; that she didn’t even consider. She meets me at the airport on a layover for her research trip to the Sorbonne, looks me up and down, and says:
‘Oh, it’s you.’
‘Gosh, so enthusiastic.’
‘What do you want from me, Thomas? I’m tired.’
‘Are you cross with me?’
‘Hmm, let me see. You portrayed me as some kind of prestige-seeking missile, and literally never gave me a fair hearing. Yes, I’d say I’m angry.’
‘Oh. Well, in fairness to me I kind of couldn’t give you a fair hearing, because Edward was not someone who would ever know you well enough to give you one. It’s his failing, really. It’s a structural issue.’
‘That’s convenient. So, what, the White guy gets all the screen time, and if he doesn’t have it in him to, I don’t know, see the black person as a person, then too bad. It’s a structural issue.’
‘I mean, you could argue that mimetically rendering relationships based on mutual ignorance is a pretty radical novelistic move. You could argue, for instance, that the fact that you’re never fully realised shows how all the various institutional and bureaucratic attempts to engineer egalitarianism on some abstract level actually preclude the kind of genuine mutual affection and flourishing that anti-racism should foster.’
‘Sounds like bullshit to me, Thomas.’
‘I mean my actual black friends – in the real world, not in the novel, not online – loved my book.’
‘Did you really just try the whole “some of my closest friends are black” line on me?’
‘Well not my closest friends, but…
‘Also in what sense do you live in the real world? You write novels. You live in Oxford – still, aged, like thirty.’
‘I’m twenty eight.’
‘Whatever.’
‘Is mentioning that my actual non-white friends liked it really so bad? Look, Liberty, I know you probably think this is really naïve and old-fashioned, but I actually think that when you have people for whom you feel real love and affection from a different demographic category, that really does help make the world better, fairer, more egalitarian. I really do think friendship and love are intensely important politically. I guess if I have one criticism of your character it’s that you’re so set on “making it” by conventional bourgeois standards – one might even say white standards – that you’ve sacrificed the kind of productive relationships that might make the world better for black people in order to be some kind of symbol of black social mobility. Which – and I’m sorry to lecture, I really don’t want to lecture – which is exactly my point about wokeness all along: it was a sort of systematic replacement of actual political or social change for this stupid game of symbolic gestures.
‘I am a symbol, Thomas. I am a fictional character. Some of us don’t get to choose to be anything else.’
‘Listen, my mother comes from an immigrant family, so I know how this works. You arrive in a foreign country. You don’t have much; you want to assimilate. You look around and everyone seems to be obsessed with bourgeois respectability – having a prestigious job, getting on in the world. So what do you do? You become, as you say, a “prestige-seeking missile”.’
‘Isn’t your mom, like, a corporate lawyer in the city? You’re taken care of. It’s kinda easy for you to reject the corporate world when you’re going to get a nice fat inheritance when you’re fifty.’
‘You are literally richer than me, Liberty. Your family owns a concrete company, like Roxane Gay’s.’
‘Yes, because you made me that way! Because it’s so much easier for you to criticise me being a striver if I’m already rich! But actually, Thomas, you’re being evasive, because quite a lot of the strivers in a place like Oxford are poor. Or Oxford poor anyway, by which I mean not really rich. And actually, I think that’s part of why you hate ambitious people. Especially black ones, and women. Because they’re unsophisticated. Not like you, with your private education. Honestly, you studied literature at university from 2016-2020 and it’s like you’ve never even heard of intersectionality.’
‘Seriously? I have literally written the most complex and honest novelistic treatment of intersectionality – real intersectionality, not just stupid shallow invocations of it – of the last ten years! Me! Not Girl, Woman, Other. Shibbloleth!
‘You’re not answering my question.’
‘You want me to answer your question? Fine. I’ll do it. Yes, I find it completely hideous and distasteful that the people who are born to some kind of disadvantage in this world are rewarded for buying into and perpetuating the very systems of oppression that put them at a disadvantage in the first place. All this “celebrating black excellence” shit. Oh look: a black woman has got a job at a prestigious private equity firm – how great! Oh look: a trans person has been put in charge of the Ministry of Clubbing Infants to Death! Wonderful!’
‘You’re getting silly now. Do you need, like, an inhaler or something?’
‘There are so many things of value in this world, Liberty, beyond simply getting on in it.’
‘Such as?’
‘Such as… I don’t know. Beauty? Truth? Family?’
‘You really want me to believe you’re not a conservative, when you come out with shit like that?’
Angelica, went to law school immediately after graduating, and is now an associate attorney for a large American firm. She spent the first few years thinking this would be temporary, and that she would jump ship to some kind of highly worthwhile position in an international NGO. Now, however, its permanence is beginning to dawn on her. She still tries her best, of course. She does some pro-bono work in the increasingly rare occasions when her schedule allows it, and is the only member of her firm to sit on both the Diversity, Equity and Inclusion advisory panel and the Sustainability Council. Next week, she will be defending a major Silicon Valley company in a class-action lawsuit, which she tells her friends is an example of the firm ‘supporting innovation’. She meets me in the lobby of her office in the City of London, declines to answer my completely disinterested inquiry as to whether she has a boyfriend, and says:
‘Listen, I don’t have much time. I have to be on a call with the US soon.’
‘It’s nice to see you doing so well.’
‘You could at least try to sound convincing.’
‘I mean it.’
‘I’m your villain.’
‘You weren’t a villain.’
‘Of course I was. I spent the first half of your novel lightly bullying everyone in my immediate vicinity, and the second half planning then executing a racially motivated hate-crime. I’m a villain.’
‘You had a lot going for you. Readers loved you. I loved writing you.’
‘What did I actually have going for me? Lots of money? Borderline personality disorder?’
‘You were beautiful, for one thing.’
‘Ah yes, great. Thank you so much for that – Male novelist creates sexy female love interest character – it’s a bit “fork found in kitchen” don’t you think? I thought novelists were supposed to be original.’
‘It was original. It was just original in ways that were so original that they weren’t immediately obvious to fundamentally unoriginal people.’
‘Come now, Thomas. Surely you can’t be under the impression that the anti-woke screed is an original invention.’
‘It’s not anti-anything, and it’s not a screed. Honestly, Angelica, it’s so galling, when you say that. People just make their minds up about all aesthetic matters based on a spontaneous gut reaction to what they think the writer’s politics are. Even if you disagree with my politics – which seems reasonable because I actually think people who do what you for a living ought to be rounded up and killed – even if you disagree with me, can’t we like literature we don’t agree with any more? What about, I don’t know… Céline or someone? You’d like him – he’s antisemitic, too.’
‘Right, ignoring that pointless allegation – which had better not appear in print, by the way – I don’t think having an adverse reaction to some racist reactionary screed like yours is necessarily all that condemnable. And yes, I know you think that makes me a philistine, but I don’t actually care.’
‘But it’s not even the “screed” itself any more. People are just mindlessly reacting to a few fragments they’ve seen on Twitter, or a few key words. They’ve become human SEO-algorithms. You know, something really weird keeps happening to me. The reviewers who gave me bad or lukewarm reviews have started reaching out – out of the blue, about six to eight months after they’ve slagged me off in print. And you know what they say? It’s always the same. They’ve seen online that I’m an anarchist, an antiracist, a big, cuddly leftie and suddenly, mysteriously, they start to reappraise my novel. They start to see glimmers of humour. Now that I know you’re a good guy, I can see that it is funny. It’s like the novel is an extension of my online persona or whatever. It’s so astonishingly unliterary.’
‘Goodness me, stop the press: white man discovers that his identity might in some way affect the way his novel is read.’
‘Don’t you think that we could do a little better, though? Rediscover the idea that the author might stand in a kind of ironic relation to his subject matter, or the way his novel is marketed?’
‘No. In fact, You know what I think? I think you’re insisting on all this “ironic relation” business precisely to repress the fact that, actually, your novel is an emanation from yourself. It literally poured out of you. It is you.’
‘Totally untrue.’
‘It’s pretty clear that I’m someone, from your life, for instance.’
‘You’re a fictional character.’
‘You’re telling me you didn’t meet girls like me at Oxford?’
‘I’m not really sure how this is relevant.
‘Did you sleep with some of them? Be honest now.’
‘If you’re insinuating that I wrote a whole book just to air grudges against former lovers, then you disappoint me. Honestly, Angelica, I thought you were a better reader than that. Didn’t you study, like, Spanish literature or something?’
‘I would’ve thought you’d be a better reader of yourself than that, Thomas. Go on, why don’t you just be honest for once. Who am I?’
‘This is ridiculous.’
‘I bet you enjoyed writing all those sex scenes with me, didn’t you? How many were there. Four? Five?’
‘They were necessary to the plot.’
‘How convenient. You know what I think? I think that behind all the irony is the fact that actually, for a while, when you were young and impressionable and still had a full head of hair, you rather liked girls like me. You liked that we were ambitious, and going places – probably something to do with your relationship with your mother, which I notice that you never talk about in print, despite your self-image as some kind of truth-teller. You liked how the world spirit seemed to flow through us. And when you were all done with Oxford, and making no money, and sitting in your hovel in SE23 or whatever in lockdown, you wanted to find a way to relive it.’
‘This is just ridiculous.’
‘And yet you’re writing it, aren’t you?’
‘You’re making me.’
‘And who’s making me make you? Honestly, Thomas. You want to talk about irony? That’s irony.’
Edward was the main character of my novel. He was, in many ways, quite a shy young man; a lot of the humour came from more forceful, charismatic characters trying to dragoon him into identity characteristics – a race, a religion – with which he didn’t really identify. He was a good student, but when his course ended, he quickly found himself adrift. He liked Shakespeare, and did a masters in early modern literature after graduating, for which he took out a sizeable loan. But he’s not sure he has the heart for academia long term. He has been looking for jobs for the last five months, with little success. When people anxiously inquire what on earth he actually plans on doing with his life, he tells them that he is writing a novel. We meet in Brockwell park, where he picks me out at once on the brown-patched slope, awkwardly waves, and says:
‘Hi. Gosh you seem happy to see me. I hope I don’t disappoint you.’
‘It’s just nice to have someone sensible to talk to. Someone with a bit of common sense. You wouldn’t believe what I’ve been dealing with from the others.’
‘Oh. Thanks, I guess.’
‘You know, Edward, you’re pretty much the only character in the novel that no-one actually objected to. Which is a minor miracle, really: people seem to think novels are real now, in case you hadn’t noticed.
‘I don’t think the fact that no-one had anything much to say about me is as much of a compliment as you think it is. I’m not actually sure I came across all that well.’
‘Oh God, not you too. What makes you think you didn’t come across well?’
‘You didn’t exactly give me much of a personality.’
‘You had something better than a personality, Edward. You had a life. You were in love.’
‘Everyone just thinks I’m you, though.’
‘That’s just what happens these days. It’s tough. for writers like us. The moment you declare some kind of non-standard ethnic origin, everyone just assumes that all you can write is autobiography. What it’s like to be an X person of Y. Anyone who knows me knows we are nothing alike. I promise.’
‘Well, I wouldn’t say nothing…’
‘No, I mean it. Nothing.’
‘Okay, you’re saying that in a really determined way.’
‘Listen, I don’t want to offend you. But I’m a little bit more… well. You know. Charismatic.’
‘Right. Thanks for that.’
‘No, no. I don’t mean it in a rude way. I just mean that you’re kind of sensible. All the exciting, flamboyant stuff comes from other people, doesn’t it? That’s sort of how the novel works.’
‘But the whole world is focalised through me. All the perceptions are mine. You have to give me some credit for that.’
‘So?’
‘So – listen, I know you’re the published novelist, so I don’t want to tell you how to do your job – but the way I see it, if you read the “flamboyant” characters, you soon notice that what’s actually going on is a kind of double-focalisation. On one level, the scene is focalised through me. But there are also these very subtle, almost Jamesian, modulations into free indirect discourse where we go into the heads of other characters. So what makes the characters interesting is actually my wit.’
‘I guess.’
‘I suppose that actually a lot of the humour in the novel comes from this technique – the sense that actually that the ‘objective’ third person voice is actually saturated with judgement – my judgement, and also perhaps your judgement – and thus suffused with a kind of irony.’
‘You’re actually the first person to notice that. I mean, I was thinking of it in a more political way – as a kind of alienation effect, where the hegemonic, “objective” voice of the white male novelist gradually shown to be as subjective and grounded in the diegetic circumstances of the text. But its’ the same thing.’
‘Oh. Hence the joke about the Verfremdungseffekt, presumably?
‘Yes! Honestly, Edward if you knew how many seemingly silly throwaway lines actually have immensely specific theoretical resonances, which precisely no-one – not the reviewers, not my fellow literature DPhils in Oxford, not anyone – notices…’
‘So I guess the real moral of the story is that everyone should go out and buy a copy of your book immediately and try and find them. That’s convenient, I suppose.’
‘It’s too late for that, Edward. It’s over. Literacy is over. Novels are dead. Irony is done.’
‘Right. Don’t you think that might be a little sweeping?’
‘Not at all.’
‘But…’
Listen, I know you’re working on your own novel, and I’m not trying to demoralise you, but…’
‘But wait. Just wait a second. Wait. You’ve done so much talking today. Just let me say one thing. I really think there’s something going on in your work that you haven’t noticed.’
‘I doubt it, but go on.’
‘You know when we were agreeing just now? You were making your theoretical points, and I was agreeing with them. Well – did you notice how for a moment, the writing surrendered its dialogic function? Your voice and my voice collapsed into a single register. I really was a thinly veiled cipher for your opinions.’
‘I’m sorry. It wasn’t very good writing.’
‘No, you’re not understanding. What I’m saying is that when that happened, did you notice that, somehow, mysteriously, that too was ironic? At the very moment the literature became one big ugly vehicle for your ideas, it sort of collapsed in on itself, and became sort of funny because of the way it trumpeted its own inauthenticity?’
‘I guess. But again, I reiterate: so what?’
‘So… it’s kind of hard to articulate, I guess. But what I’m trying to get at is that I think there’s a sense in which irony is actually intrinsic to human communication, and that in a way the discursive settings which circumscribe irony end up being the most ironic of all. Irony comes bursting out of all human communication like water from a broken pipe. Suddenly, spontaneously, all the kids in the lecture hall start laughing. The long piece of earnest AI-generated drivel becomes impossible to take seriously.’
‘Look, Edward, I really appreciate you’re trying to cheer me up. But I kind of think that if you need to reach for all this airy metaphysics just to do so, then it kind of means that I’m fucked. The novel is over.’
‘But you don’t really think that.’
‘I do. I just said I did. ‘
‘Yes, but remember what I just said about irony. Words do far more than just saying what they mean.’
‘The novel is over, Edward.’
‘If the novel is over, why are you writing another one?’
‘What? What makes you think I’m writing another one.’
‘Admit it. You’re writing another novel. You’re nearly done with it, in fact. And it’s even more complex, and allusive, and ambitious, and absolutely no-one will understand it, and you love that about it. You love it.’
‘How did you…?’
‘Isn’t it obvious?’
‘Nothing is obvious to me any more.’
‘I know it, Thomas, because I’m you. I mean it. You’ll never admit it, and no-one will ever understand it, but in some very important, mysterious way, I’m you.’

I suppose it's an obvious point that the author, in fact, did not fail as a novelist.
Click bait title, then a self indulgent post about being a successful published author. Truly grim. 123 sycophantic likes. No wonder there are only average works of literature these days.